That’s MBTI to you, Buster!
Most people have their first exposure to the Myers-BriggsType Indicator (MBTI) assessment either in a college psychology class, a life coaching session or in a work-related retreat / team building exercise. For those of you who aren’t familiar with the test, participants are given a (psychologically loaded) questionnaire that’s been specifically devised to determine individual preferences and based on those, to then extrapolate the test taker’s decision-making process and world view.
In context, it can be a useful tool. When participants get their four letter code that determines their personality type, they then typically get the equivalent of a score card to determine what the letters mean and to offer some guidelines on the types of decision-making process that they make. Again, in context it can be a useful tool where participants might see themselves and their decision-making process in a whole new light.
However, there always seems to be at least one person in a session who finds this to be something between a milestone and a revelatory experience and the next thing you know, every discussion with this person centers around Myers-Briggs. Every interaction is analyzed and put through the Myers-Briggs filter. “Oh well he must be an “I” which means that….”.
And then, eventually, someone calls them on their nonsense.
Myers-Briggs typing starts to break down in the real world, because while it’s not a bad contextual lens for gleaning some information, it’s not a good lens on its own and it certainly has limited validity as the sole filter for information. Additionally, people don’t dig being typecast in any scenario, even when you’re trying to be helpful.
“Cure’s All that Ail’s ya!”
The web is full of these observations and cure-alls for whatever ail’s ya. “Become a guitar god in a week by following these 3 weird simple rules.” Or forums where one observation is yielded, “I had good success using product x with gear y” and soon you have other people who have never used product x or gear y saying, “Well if you use gear y YOU HAVE TO USE product x!!!”
Take any one-size fits all methodology, philosophy, strategy or any solution with a BIG grain of salt because, in my own experience, there is no one panacea for anything. Just as there is no one filter that will make previously hidden elements of the world fully visible and comprehensible to you.
Instant gratification and false entitlement
The simple fact is that things that are worth having, have to be worked for.
As a society, we have mutated this concept through advertising and sold people on the concept that because they do work hard in other areas of their life, that they deserve everything.
“It might take you 3 years of saving to buy that 60″ flat screen TV. You’ve worked hard establishing a line of good credit and you deserve to be comfortable in your twice re-financed home. Pull that piece of plastic out of your pocket and you can walk home with it today!” – where you will set it up, take it for granted almost instantly and then spend 5 years paying it off and paying more than twice the actual cost of the item.
As Pascal said, “A trifle consoles us, for a trifle distresses us.” It should be called instant gratification because you’re gratified in an instant and your gratification lasts just as long.
Guitar playing isn’t like that. Certainly pedagogy and information transfer has occurred to the point where people can progress technically much more quickly on the instrument than ever before.
But the problem is that guitar playing isn’t merely a skill like typing.
More than a skill set, a guitar is a vehicle for expression. Technical facility might impress people, but if there’s nothing behind it in terms of depth of expression, you won’t make a long-lasting impression on them.
Having the depth to truly say something, takes time. Plain and simple.
A good way to think about this is something a great luthier John Harper told me about guitar. As you play guitar over time, the vibrations of the notes actually affects the wood on a cellular level. The vibrations literally change the make up of the guitar over time. This is why guitars that have been “played in” over time sound completely different than they did off the shelf.
There are plenty of shortcuts to becoming a fast guitar player.
There are plenty of shortcuts to becoming a better guitar player.
There are no shortcuts to becoming a great guitar player.
Truly great players, have a completely different relationship to music than most other people. Music not only nourishes them, but eventually the musician starts communicating with the music rather than just the audience. That conversation helps them gain further insight into themselves and actually helps to develop them more as people.
Not only is there no shortcut for that – but if you think about it, you really might not want a shortcut in that area. For example, if you had the opportunity to meet anyone in history would you rather have the conversation with them when you were 4 years old or 34? It might be exciting to meet them when you’re 4, but you really wouldn’t have anything to say. It’s only with the passage of time and experience that you can start to meet the music part way and have that conversation. For every person, that time is different but putting the time in now gets you closer and closer to being able to have that dialog.
Be wary of the cure-all, the quick fix and the over-arching shortcut. Work hard and work passionately and know that what you truly put of yourself into anything can ultimately pay dividends for you.
As always, thanks for reading!